3 Talking Points: Professional Game Partnership Announced as Steve Borthwick Gets 'Final Say' on 25 England Players - Page 2 of 2 - Ruck

3 Talking Points: Professional Game Partnership Announced as Steve Borthwick Gets ‘Final Say’ on 25 England Players

2. How the RFU and Premiership clubs will sort out disagreements over players

Whilst on paper the decision to allocate 25 Enhanced EPS and 50 EPS contracts will ensure that both the England team and the Premiership clubs needs are met, there will inevitably be some differences of agenda regarding whether a player should be playing for their club or country, or rested entirely.

Last Kick Drop Goal celebrations from Marcus Smith of England to win the match during the Guinness Six Nations Match between England and Ireland at Twickenham Stadium, Twickenham, London on March 9th 2024. – PHOTO: Tom Sandberg/PPAUK

BILL SWEENEY: “For the enhanced EPS players, the 25 (contracts), Steve has an oversight and say on anything to do with S&C (strength and conditioning), individual development programmes and he’ll work with the clubs to develop that. There will obviously be occasions where there is a disagreement or an inability to come to a final conclusion, but that’s the whole purpose of the men’s professional rugby board and an independent chair, so we’ll take those discussions there and resolve them internally.”

PHIL WINSTANLEY: “Very simply speaking, Steve will have final say on S&C (strength and conditioning) and medical issues for those players in the enhanced EPS. Director of Rugby (of Premiership clubs) will have final say on selection of those players and on S&C, selection and medical for the non-EPS.

Steve Borthwick, Head Coach of England Rugby during the England Rugby Captains Run ahead of the Six Nations Match between Wales and England at Principality Stadium, London on 24 Feb 2023 (Photo: Tom Sandberg/PPAUK)

“The question that we spent the most time on was ‘how do we ensure that the decision you’re making is reasonable?’ And that’s where the PRB will come in and monitor that. It won’t necessarily – it could – make a recommendation to change a decision, it won’t necessarily override that, it will just ensure that a decision that is made is a reasonable decision.”

“If we are going into hypothetical situations, if we are going into a Six Nations and the week before Steve says he’s not fit enough and shouldn’t play, that really isn’t an S&C decision at that point in time as he’s not going to change his fitness in a week. So the selection will be the (Premiership) Director of Rugby’s.”


3. RFU give Steve Borthwick full vote of confidence – despite key coaching exits

A matter aside from the contracts, was Bill Sweeney’s comments on the shock departures of two of the England Rugby back-room staff. Last month, the England players and board were stunned by the unexpected exit of Head of Strength and Conditioning Aled Walters and Defence Coach Felix Jones.

Felix Jones, Defence Coach of England during the Guinness Six Nations Match between England and Ireland at Twickenham Stadium, Twickenham, London on March 9th 2024. – PHOTO: Tom Sandberg/PPAUK

Whilst Walters has confirmed his future within Andy Farrell’s Ireland set-up, the verdict is unclear as to where Jones will end up next. Negotiations are reportedly still ongoing with the Irishman, yet Sweeney was still disappointed with his exit. Despite the two figures quitting the England staff, Sweeney expressed how the RFU still give Steve Borthwick the full vote of confidence to continue his role as head coach.

BILLY SWEENEY: “We’ll replace Aled. There will be someone else coming in on S&C for the England team. Aled wasn’t part of the consideration of thinking around the enhanced EPS. We’re obviously very disappointed (at Jones leaving). A lot of you were down in New Zealand and we’ve seen some good momentum and progression in terms of how the England team has been playing under Steve as head coach.

Steve Borthwick, Director of Rugby of Leicester Tigers speak to Aled Walters, Head of Physical Performance of Leicester Tigers during the Gallagher Premiership Rugby Semi Final Match between Leicester Tigers and Northampton Saints at Mattioli Woods Welford Road on 11 June. Photo: Tom Sandberg/PPAUK

“We’ve got a really nice blend between experience and young players coming in. There is huge excitement around the squad about how the team played at the back end of the Six Nations and in the summer. New Zealand was really encouraging. We’ve got the autumn coming up so for that to happen was massively disappointing. It came out of the blue. It was totally unexpected.

“What I can say though is that Steve has absolute 100 per cent support from us – from me personally and of the RFU. I can also say categorically he has the full support 100 per cent of the squad. If you talk to the players, they were quite keen to deliver a message that they’ve got a really enjoyable camp.

Steve Borthwick, Head Coach of England during the Guinness Six Nations Match between England and Ireland at Twickenham Stadium, Twickenham, London on March 9th 2024. – PHOTO: Tom Sandberg/PPAUK

“They seem to genuinely enjoy being in camp and they want to ensure we’ve got coaches coming in who are passionate about our journey, will buy into this new structure, and are committed to working for England. It was disappointing but these things happen. We’re now focused on moving forward.”